No. 24
How does bread tray footprint width affect the number of trays required per delivery route for wide-format products?
- 6 sections
- 3 tables
Footprint width changes the number of trays on a route only through one number: how many packs of the product fit in one tray. Trays per route is the product count at each stop divided by packs per tray, rounded up stop by stop. A wider tray cuts that count when the extra width lets another row of packs fit; if the packs still fit the same number of rows, the wider tray carries the same load in a bigger tray. Pallet, rail and dolly geometry is a separate question: it changes how many trays fit in the truck, not how many trays the route needs.
Two questions people mix up
| Question | What answers it | What footprint does |
|---|---|---|
| How many trays does this route need? | Packs per stop ÷ packs per tray, rounded up at each stop | Changes packs per tray, in steps |
| How many trays fit in the truck? | Positions per truck x trays per column | Changes positions per truck, in steps |
Keep them apart in the analysis. A wider tray can lower the first number and also lower the second, and the net effect on trucks depends on both.
Packs per tray: width pays only at whole rows
Packs sit in whole rows. The count is:
packs per tray = (interior length ÷ pack length, rounded down) x (interior width ÷ pack width, rounded down) x layers
Try both orientations of the pack and keep the larger result.
For example, imagine a sub roll pack measuring 12.5 x 6.5 inches laid flat in one layer, and trays with an interior length of 25.0 inches:
| Interior width | Packs per tray |
|---|---|
| 20.0 in | 6 |
| 21.0 in | 6 |
| 22.0 in | 6 |
| 26.0 in | 8 |
Going from 20 to 22 inches adds nothing for this pack, because three rows of 6.5 inches need 19.5 inches and four rows need 26.0. The gain arrives only when the width reaches the next multiple of the pack width. Measure the real interior (not the outside dimensions on the catalog) and the real pack, including its closure and any bulge, before concluding that a wider tray helps.
Manufacturers make the general point in their own materials. SPF Plastic Group, for example, says the 22-inch width of its SPF 650 “gives you more lateral packing room than narrower models, which means fewer trays per route for wide-format products like sub rolls and oversized bun packs.” The pack-fit calculation above is how to check that claim for your product.
Trays per route: rounding at each stop
Trays are delivered stop by stop, so each stop rounds up separately. For example, imagine a route of 10 stops each taking 14 sub roll packs:
- 6 packs per tray: 3 trays per stop, 30 trays per route
- 8 packs per tray: 2 trays per stop, 20 trays per route
Pooled across the route, 140 packs would fit in 24 or 18 trays (140 ÷ 6 = 23.3 and 140 ÷ 8 = 17.5, rounded up); the per-stop rounding adds the rest. That is why a product ordered in small quantities per store can be more sensitive to packs per tray than route averages suggest. Run the calculation with your actual order sizes per stop, not route totals.
Trays per truck: positions and columns
A wider tray may also change how trays ride:
- Dollies. A tray needs a dolly that fits it. SPF Plastic Group, for instance, lists a 26.6 x 22.6 inch dolly and a larger 26.6 x 29.6 inch dolly alongside trays such as its 26.9 x 22.0 inch SPF 650 and its 25.5 x 28.5 inch SPF 660; a larger dolly can mean fewer dolly positions in the truck.
- Rails. Route trucks with rails take trays of a set footprint; a different footprint can need a different rail spacing.
- Pallets. On a 48 x 40 inch pallet, a 26.9 x 22.0 inch tray fits two columns with the 22.0-inch sides along the 48-inch edge; whether a wider tray still fits two depends on its exact size.
Count positions in your actual truck layout for each candidate tray, then multiply by trays per column; how tray height sets trays per column is covered in our guide to tray height and truck capacity.
A note on European tray sizes
European container sizing works on a different module. The most common Euro container sizes are 600 x 400 mm and 400 x 300 mm, which stack together to fill a 1,200 x 800 mm Euro-pallet, as the encyclopedia entry on Euro containers describes. U.S. bread trays follow their own sizes: SPF Plastic Group’s SPF 620 to 660 and BB209 bread trays and baskets list outside dimensions from 25.5 to 27 inches by 20.5 to 28.5 inches, so European rules of thumb about trays per pallet layer do not carry over. Do the arithmetic with your own tray and pallet or dolly sizes.
The full comparison for a wider tray
| Effect | Direction for a wider tray | How to measure |
|---|---|---|
| Packs per tray | Up only if a new row fits | Pack-fit calculation |
| Trays per route | Down when packs per tray rises | Per-stop rounding with real orders |
| Positions per truck | Same or down | Count in the truck layout |
| Trays in the pool | Down when trays per route falls | Pool sizing from cycle time |
| Wash throughput | Fewer, larger trays | Wash line rate for the new size |
| Store fit | Depends on shelf or display | Store survey |
The store side of the decision is covered in our guide to footprint and merchandising.
A wider tray earns its place on a route when the pack-fit calculation adds a row for the products that drive tray count, and the truck still carries the route’s trays after the position count is redone; if either check fails, the narrower tray is the better choice for that route.